Pocket Camcorder Comparison

Overview

These recordings are part of a comparison project to review the Flip Ultra HD, the Kodak Zi8, and the Samson Q3HD. All videos were recorded at 720/60fps and using the built-in microphone on each camera

Note, any "hum" you might hear is the HVAC in the room, and yes, I know, I cut my own head off in the beginning of each video :-) Also, the videos begin after about 10 seconds (the time it took me to turn all the cameras on)

I'm happy to receive any comments/corrections and I am aware that Cisco just eliinated the Flip Camera.

Flip UltraHD (8Gb)

 

Kodak Zi8


Samson Q3HD

Product Comparison


Flip Ultra HD (8Gb) Kodak Zi8 Samson Q3HD
Website http://store.theflip.com/en-us/products/UltraHD8GB2HR.aspx http://store.kodak.com/store/ekconsus/en_US/pd/Zi8_Pocket_Video_Camera/productID.156585800 http://www.samsontech.com/products/productpage.cfm?prodID=2062
Price (Approximate) $199 $179 (list, generally much cheaper)
$299
Windows/Mac Compatible Win/Mac Win/Mac Win/Mac
Recording Memory 8Gb
No SD Card Slot
128Mb Internal Memory
SD Card Slot
64Mb Internal Memory
SD Card Slot
Recording Output Format mp4 mov mov
Capture Specs 720p/60 fps (1280 × 720, 60 fps)

Video: H.264 (MP4)

Audio: AAC
1080p (1920 × 1080, 30 fps)
720p/60 fps (1280 × 720, 60 fps)
720p (1280 × 720, 30 fps)
WVGA (848 × 480, 30 fps)

Video: H.264 (MOV),

Audio: AAC LC
1080p (1920 × 1080, 30 fps)
720p/60 fps (1280 × 720, 60 fps)
720p (1280 × 720, 30 fps)
WVGA (848 × 480, 60 fps)
WVGA (848 × 480, 30 fps)

Video: MPEG-4 AVC/H.264 (MOV)

Audio: 44.1/48/96kHz 16/24-bit WAV (PCM) or AAC up to 320kbps
Digital Zoom Yes Yes Yes
Stills Yes (Extract Stills with FlipShare Software) Yes (Directly on Camera) No
Batteries (Battery Life) Flip Ultra Battery Pack (Rechargeable,Included)
3 AAA Batteries

1.5hrs with Rechargeable Batteries
KODAK Li-Ion Rechargeable Digital Camera Battery KLIC-7004 (Rechargeable,Included)

2hrs with Rechargeable Batteries
Two standard AA batteries or NiMH rechargeable batteries
(Standard AA batteries included)

???
External Power while recording No Yes, AC Adapter (Included) Yes, AC Adapter (Purchased Separately)
AC Recharging With adapter (Purchased Separately) Yes (Adapter Included) With adapter (Purchased Separately)
External Microphone No Yes No (Line-in only)
USB Connection Yes Yes Yes
Bundled Editing/Uploading Software Yes - FlipShare Yes - ARCSOFT MEDIA IMPRESSION Software for Kodak (PC only) Yes - HandyShare
HDMI Output Yes Yes Yes
Tripod Mount Yes Yes Yes

https://docs.google.com/document/pub?id=1z-HIToH8KALi-WQn0MOJ2qQ5Tmgm6En2zU2jpB2_soI