Synopsis:
Instructional Objectives: This course will:
- Introduce basic reference tools (print and electronic)
- Discuss how to evaluate and select reference tools.
- Learn about the importance of interpersonal skills and questioning strategies in the reference interaction.
- Explore the impact of information technologies.
- Learn about the new models and the evaluation of reference services.
Learning Objectives: Upon completion of course, students will be able to:
- Demonstrate knowledge of the development of reference service and the basic concepts.
- Use reference service guidelines and policies as appropriate.
- Articulate and model the critical functions of the reference interaction, the interpersonal dimensions, and questioning strategies.
- Analyze the impact of information technologies on reference services (networking, online sources, and the Internet).
- Discuss criteria to be used in evaluating reference sources and collections.
- Identify selection principles and evaluation tools involved in building a reference collection.
- Identify selection principles involved in providing reference sources for particular users in specific settings.
- Use a simple search strategy in providing reference assistance using a variety of formats (print, electronic, other media).
- Use various reference sources to find answers to reference questions.
Organization of the Course: This course consists of lectures, discussions, exercises and class activities. Students are expected to do all assigned readings, to examine reference materials as assigned, to come to class prepared to discuss readings, assignments, and to actively participate. Active participation includes, but is not limited to the following: being informed by assigned readings and demonstrating this by contributing to class discussions, asking relevant questions or challenging points raised in class and suggesting new ways of looking at things.
Assignments and Criteria of Assessment:
Participation and Attendance 10%
Assignments 15%
Short Paper #1 20%
Short Paper #2 20%
Webliography 20%
IPL Project 15%
Total 100%
Major Course Readings:
Cassell, K.A. and U. Hiremath. (2009) Reference and Information Services in the 21st Century: An Introduction. 2nd ed. New York: Neal-Schuman.
Ross, C.S. ( 2009) Conducting the Reference Interview. 2nd ed. New York: Neal-Schuman.
Additional readings and exercises are listed in the course schedule or will be assigned in class.
Required Papers:
Short Paper #1 – Interpersonal Communication in the Reference Interview
The purpose of this assignment is to provide the student with some experience with reference interactions from the user perspective. In this assignment, each student will formulate a reference question that is based upon a previous assignment or experience to which the student already knows the answer. The student will then choose four (4) different libraries having a reference department or librarian-staffed virtual reference service, and will ask the same question 4 times (one time at each library) as a “surrogate user” in four different ways: in person, by phone, by e-mail and by chat. An analysis of the interactions will result in a paper of 5-7 pages double-spaced.
Your analysis should look first at each interaction separately with separate subheadings (e.g. Interaction 1: Face to Face) to see if all the components of a good reference interview are present. The second part of your analysis should be a comparison of both the efficiency of the format (e.g. did you get the correct answer in a reasonable time frame) and the quality of the interpersonal interaction (e.g. how did the interaction make you feel about the way the librarian regarded you as a user). Your emphasis should be on the interpersonal communication and not on the answer provided. The final part of your analysis should be a personal reflection on which format you most liked and why. You are expected to include a short bibliography of sources used.
Short Paper #2 – Search Process Project
This assignment is designed to give the student experience using indexes and full-text databases. Choose a topic from a list of suggested topics. You are to search for journal articles (no books, newspapers or websites) on your approved topic as if you were doing a 20-30 page term paper. Acceptable journal indexes and full-text databases are the multidisciplinary indexes and databases and subject indexes listed in chaptes 8 and 9.
- Identify 15 of the best articles, the ones you would obtain and read for this mythical paper. All articles should be from quality journals and at least 3 pages in length. List them in a bibliography using APA style
- Describe the process you used to locate the articles. How did you approach the search and what was your strategy? Did you ask for help? Was the help “helpful”? Would you approach the search in the same way were you to do it over?
- Provide an annotated bibliography (APA style) of the indexes/databases that you used. Describe the content of each index /database and the dates of coverage. Citation example: Academic Search Premier. Ipswich, MA: Ebsco Industries, Inc., 1975 - .
Short Paper #3 – Webliography
Use the same topic and develop a webliography using several search engines, meta-search engines and subject directories. Suggested search engines include Google (www.google.com), Yahoo (www.yahoo.com), MSN Search (www.msn.com), Exalead (www.exalead.com), Bing (www.bing.com) and Ask (www.ask.com). Suggested meta-search engines include Dogpile (www.dogpile.com), and Clusty (www.clusty.com).Suggested subject directories include Infomine (http://infomine.ucr.edu) and Librarians’ Internet Index (www.lii.org).Any search engines listed in chapter 13 are acceptable.
Create a short paper listing 7-10 of the best web sites you found using the evaluation criteria in chapter 13. Use commercial sites (.com) only if absolutely necessary.
On the top line state the subject you were searching followed by a brief paragraph of introduction to the topic. Then, in alphabetical order, list the web site names using APA format and a brief description with short evaluative comments. Do not print out web pages and hand them in. Put “Prepared by” and your name and date on the bottom.
Class Assignments
Notes from your preparation for each class assignment must be turned in.
Class Project
Rutgers belongs to the IPL (Internet Public Library) Consortium. All students in this class will be trained and will be expected to answer questions posed through IPL.org. More details will be given to you.
Course Schedule
| Class | Topic | Assignment |
| Class 1 | Introduction Meet in classroom Library Orientation at Alexander Library Guest Speaker Kevin Mulcahy, Humanities Librarian, Alexander Library (4th floor lecture hall) | RUSA Definitions of Reference (www.ala.org/ala/mgrps/divs/rusa/resources/guidelines/ definitionsreference.cfm) Read Cassell & Hiremath, chapter 1 |
| Class 2 | Bibliographies and Bibliographic Networks | Read Cassell & Hiremath, chapter 4 Class Assignment : Examine the following bibliographies and be prepared to discuss what kinds of questions you could answer with these reference works: Books in Print, Ulrich’s International Periodical Directory, Gale Directory of Publications and Broadcast Media, Literary Market Place, WorldCat (hand in your notes) Introduction to the IPL |
| Class 3 | Reference Interaction – Face to Face and Virtual | Read Cassell & Hiremath, chapter 2 and Ross, chapters 1, 2 ,3, 4, 5 and RUSA Guidelines for Behavioral Performance of Reference and Information Services Providers www.ala.org/mgrps/divs/rusa/resources/guidelines/guidelinesbehavioral.cfm |
| Class 4 | Ready Reference, Dictionaries and Encyclopedias | Read Cassell & Hiremath, chapters 5, 6 and 7 Class assignment: Compare the following resources in print and online and note the differences between them: Roget’s Thesaurus (www.thesaurus.com), Bartlett’s Familiar Quotations (www.bartelby.com/100), Occupational Outlook Handbook (www.bls.gov/oco/), Information Please Almanac (www.infoplease.com) compare with Time Almanac: with Information Please and Merriam-Webster’s Collegiate Dictionary & Thesaurus (www.m-w.com/dictionary.htm). Pick a subject and compare the treatment of the subject in three encyclopedias. Use at least one general encyclopedia. (hand in your notes) |
| Class 5 | Searching Indexes and Full-Text Databases | Read Cassell & Hiremath, chapters 3 & 8 Look at “Evaluating Scholarly Content Online” at www.lib.berkeley.edu/scholarly communication/ SHORT PAPER #1 DUE |
| Class 6 | Using the Internet for Reference | Read Cassell & Hiremath, chapter 13 Read “Deep Web” in Wikipedia. Review Best Free Reference Web Sites 2009 www.ala.org/ala/mgrps/divs/rusa/sections/mars/ marspubs/marsbestfreewebsites/marsbestfree2009.cfm SUBJECT FOR SHORT PAPER #2 DUE |
| Class 7 | Virtual Reference | Read Bromberg, P. (April 2003) Managing a statewide virtual reference service: How Q and A NJ works. Computers in Libraries 23(4):26-31 Read Ross, chapter 6 LIST OF DATABASES FOR SHORT PAPER #2 DUE Guest speaker – Beth Cackowski, Q&A NJ |
| Class 8 | Geographical and Biographical Sources | Read Cassell & Hiremath, chapters 10 and 11 Class Assignment: Choose a famous person living or dead. Find information about him/her in 3 different biographical sources mentioned in your readings (no books). Use Wikipedia for one source. Then fact check the biographies against a source that you consider the most reputable. Hand in your notes. |
| Class 9 | Health, Law and Business Resources | Read Cassell & Hiremath, chapter 9 RUSA Guidelines for Medical, Legal and Business Responses (www.ala.org/ala/mgrps/divs/rusa/resources/guidelines/ guidelinesmedical.cfm) Select one of the three areas – health, law or business – and review three sources listed in the textbook. Decide what would be a good title for a public library and what would be a good title for an academic library. SHORT PAPER #2 DUE |
| Class 10 | Virtual Reference | Read Ross, chapter 6 and bring the Ross book to class Guest speaker – Professor Marie Radford |
| Class 11 | Government Information | Read Cassell & Hiremath, chapter 12 Class Assignment: Examine the following government resources: Catalog of U.S. Government Publications (catalog.gpo.gov/F), U.S. Government Manual (www.gpoaccess.gov/gmanual/index.html), GPO Access (www.gpoaccess.gov), Thomas (www.thomas.gov), USA.gov (www.usa.gov). What kinds of questions could you answer from these sources? |
| Class 12 | Service to Children & Young Adults | Read Cassell & Hiremath, chapter 15, Review Ross, chapter 5 SHORT PAPER #3 DUE Guest Speaker – Ellen Loughran |
| Class 13 | Selection and evaluation Reader’s Advisory Service | Read Cassell & Hiremath, chapter 17 Class assignment: Look at the following selection tools and note similarities and differences: Choice, Booklist, Library Journal and ARBA (American Reference Books Annual). In what type of library are they best used? Read Cassell & Hiremath, chapter 14, Ross chapter 7 Wyatt, N. (July 2007) An RA Big Think. Library Journal 132(12):40-43. Class assignment: Choose a title from the New York Times bestseller lists for the last year and using RA tools, particularly NoveList, find three readalikes. Be prepared to discuss your choices in class. |
| Class 14 | Information Literacy Management and Assessment | Read Cassell & Hiremath, chapter 16 Write a short essay (one page) on what you think is an effective way to provide information literacy in a library Read Cassell & Hiremath chapters 18, 19, and pp. 422-3 Be prepared to discuss the various reference service models |
| Class 15 | Reference 2.0 The future | Read Cassell & Hiremath, chapter 20 and 21 |
Attendance Policy: Attendance at all class meetings is highly recommended. A student who must be absent from a class meeting still has certain responsibilities:
- To inform the professor in advance, or if advance notice is not possible, as soon after the absence as possible (by phone or by e-mail)
- To arrange for delivery to the professor of any assignment due at the class meeting. Faxes and e-mailed papers will not be accepted unless given permission.
- To obtain notes, handouts, etc. from a classmate (in anticipation of this need, each student is advised to exchange telephone numbers with one or two others in the class)
- Points may be deducted for unexcused absences, coming late to class, or leaving class early.
Written Work: These guidelines must be followed for all assignments and papers. Papers that do not meet these standards will be returned to the student for resubmission before grading. Print out your paper and proof read it before submitting. Do not proof read from the screen.
- Students must always keep second copies of all assignments that re turned in. In the case of a piece of written work becoming lost, regardless of fault, it is the responsibility of the student to provide a second copy.
- Assignments are to be typed, double spaced with at least 1” margins on all sides of the paper.
- All papers are to be free from spelling, grammatical and typing errors. Use no less than 12-point type and number all pages.
- Underline or put all titles of books or databases in italics.
- Assignments are to be handed in as hard paper copies only. No faxed or e-mailed papers will be accepted unless prior permission is given.
- Put a single staple in the upper left-hand corner – no plastic covers or folders.
- Include a cover sheet for all assignments with name of class/section, student and paper plus semester and date. A blank page at the end is not required.
- Papers are due at the beginning of class on the dates noted. Late papers will be marked down one letter grade unless the student has obtained prior permission of the professor (in the case of illness, etc.)
- Papers will be prepared in accordance with the APA (American Psychological Association) style available at http://www.apastyle.org Although APA requires an abstract, since all your papers are short, no abstract of the paper is required. Additional information with sample citations for citing print as well as electronic sources is provided at http://owl.english.purdue.edu//owl/resource/560/01/
- All material quoted or paraphrased from another source must be properly cited.
Cell Phone Policy: Cell phones are to be set to vibrate or turned off during class.
Student Agreement: Attendance at this class signifies that the student has agreed to abide by and adhere to the policies and regulations specified above. It is understood that the instructor may adapt or change this syllabus and the assignments contained within it according to circumstances that may arise during the course of the class.
Academic Integrity and Student Support Services:
The consequences of scholastic dishonesty are serious. Rutgers’ academic integrity policy is at http://academicintegrity.rutgers.edu/integrity.shtml
http://www.scc.rutgers.edu/douglass/sal/plagiarism/intro.html
Rutgers University Libraries and Information Literacy Instruction
http://www.libraries.rutgers.edu/
Statement about Learning Disabilities: Dean Karen Novick (knovick@scils.rutgers.edu) should be notified if students need any special accommodation (long term or short term) due to learning disabilities or physical disabilities.
Disability Support Services http://disabilityservices.rutgers.edu/
School of Communication and Information www.comminfo.rutgers.edu