Email Messages Requesting Information and My Response

These messages were transferred without change. They appear exactly as received, although personal and institutional identities have been eliminated. Key elements in the message are highlighted in red.

Date: Sun, 09 Mar 1997 16:18:09 -0500
To: kvander@scils.rutgers.edu
Subject: Young adult literature

Ms. Vandergrift,
I am a junior in high school exploring many different aspects of American literature. For my scrapbook (in my Honors American Literature class), I would like to place a particular emphasis on young adult fiction. To me, it seems that writing for adolescents would present many problems that other literature does not. I do not understand how an adult writer would go about writing anything that would interest a wide variety of readers at such a confusing age (both for the adolescents themselves and those trying to reach them!). If you have time, I would love for you to answer a few questions I have.
What makes young adult fiction appeal to adolescents? Is it the characters, the themes, the length of the books, the subjects covered, or a combination? How does an author choose subject matter that interests readers of that age?
Why do many young adult fiction novels appeal to older adults also? When did authors first begin writing specifically for young adults and what made them do so? Who were some of the first young adult fiction writers?
Are there any poets, short story writers, and/or dramatists whose writing is aimed specifically at adolescents? If so, could you give me a few names of the authors and their works?
Thank you very much for your time. It is greatly appreciated!
Sincerely,
[A female junior high school student]

Date: Mon, 10 Mar 1997 10:18:11 -0500
From: "Kay E. Vandergrift" kvander@scils.rutgers.edu
Subject: Young Adult Literature

It sounds as if you are going to have an interesting scrapbook for your project. Now, to try to answer some of your questions.
I think it's a combination of all the things you mentioned that makes young adult fiction--character, theme, length, subject. (I'm sure you expected me to say that, but it is true.)
Your second question is a little more difficult, and there are many answers. Many authors say that they don't choose their subject matter; it chooses them. It is fascinating to hear or read what authors say about this. Some feel compelled to write a particular story; others tell of planning to write one story but "finding another on the page." Often they talk about their work in such mystical terms. Many novels which we now consider young adult fiction were written for adults and later taken over by young adults--a lot of the "classics" and Catcher in the Rye, for instance. Even today an author may write a novel thinking it is for adults, or with no specific audience in mind, only to have an editor decide that it is a young adult novel. Of course, many writers do deliberately decide to write for young adults. The best of them still have some sense of what it feels like to be an adolescent and can use that in their storytelling. It's not enough for an older person to remember his/her own adolescence because so much changes so quickly. But some of the basic feelings are still the same--even if the specific trappings change. The good writer of young adult fiction finds ways to tune into today's kids and their concerns while peeling back all the layers of time and adult concerns to get to those feelings of what it was--and is-- to be an adolescent. As you can imagine, this is very, very difficult and only a few can do it really well.
Your next question is easy. young adult fiction appeals to many adults because, at its best, it is just good story! And one of the amazing things about being a reader is that readers can, vicariously at least, be any age and live through any experiences.
There are different opinions about the beginnings of young adult fiction. A lot of people say Maureen Daly's Seventeen Summer in the 1940s was the first young adult novel. In the 1950s Betty Cavanna, Rosemary Du Jardin and Anne Emery wrote for young adult females and Henry Gregor Felson, John Tunis, and others were popular with young men. Most publishers set up special young adult divisions beginning in the late sixties or early seventies. S.E. Hinton's The Outsiders, written when Susie Hinton was a teenager is often considered the beginning of modern young adult fiction.
Poetry is more ageless than fiction and thus what you will find is a number of collections of poems selected for young adults. Check in your local public library or your school library and you should find a large number of such collections. The same thing is true for short stories and drama--they are least age-bound.
Among the most popular fiction writers for young adults are the following: Robert Cormier, Cynthia Voigt, Robin McKinley, David Klass, Donna Jo Napoli. There are many more but this is a start. If you visit my pages called "Kay's 100 List" you will find a lengthy list of young adult titles that I ask my graduate students to read. Go to:
http://www.scils.rutgers.edu/special/kay/100list.html
You will also find pages at my site on coming-of-age novels that are adult novels written about young adults facing growing up under vastly differing circumstances, but remember these are adult novels. Go to:
http://www.scils.rutgers.edu/special/kay/age.html
http://www.scils.rutgers.edu/special/kay/male.html
You can print out any of these pages to use in your scrapbook. Hope this helps in your project! Good Luck! Kay